Skip to content

Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie

Bott boi: chicken stew with square egg noodles, no crust

In Lancaster County a pot pie is not a pie at all: bott boi is a thick chicken stew with potatoes, celery and saffron in which big squares of rolled egg dough are boiled like noodles, served at firehouse suppers and Amish and Mennonite family dinners. It is soft, comforting and golden. Chef's tip: drop the dough squares in one at a time into a rolling boil so they don't stick together in a lump.
Total time
130 min
Difficulty
medium
Serves
6
One step at a time, big text, timers, read-aloud. Your screen stays on.

Ingredients

Serves6

For the stew

For the dough

  • 9 oz plain flour
  • ½ tsp salt
  • 2 eggs
  • 3 tbsp water

Shop this recipe on Amazon

Fresh ingredients (6)

Links open Amazon in a new tab. As an Amazon Associate, WhatToEat.Today earns from qualifying purchases.

Method

0/6 done
  1. Step 1: Put the 2 ⅝ lb chicken thighs and drumsticks, skin on in a large pot with the 8 ¼ cups water, 1 onion, half the 1 ½ celery sticks, 1 pinch saffron threads, 2 tsp salt and ½ tsp black pepper. Bring to the boil, skim, then simmer for 1 hour until the meat falls from the bone.

    65 min
  2. Step 2: Meanwhile mix the 9 oz plain flour, ½ tsp salt, 2 eggs and 3 tbsp water to a stiff dough, knead 2 minutes, cover and rest 30 minutes.

    35 min
  3. Step 3: Lift out the chicken, cool slightly, then shred the meat, throwing away skin and bones.

    10 min
  4. Step 4: Roll the dough on a floured worktop until 2 mm thin and cut into 5 cm squares.

    10 min
  5. Step 5: Bring the broth back to a rolling boil, add the 1 ⅛ lb potatoes and the rest of the 1 ½ celery sticks, then drop in the dough squares one by one, stirring gently. A common mistake is adding them all at once, which makes a gluey lump.

    10 min
  6. Step 6: Cover and simmer 20 minutes until the potatoes and noodles are tender and the broth has thickened. Return the chicken, heat until piping hot, and stir in the 3 tbsp parsley.

    22 min

Nutrition per serving

Calories
450 kcal
Protein
34 g
Carbs
40 g
Fat
16 g
Fibre
3 g

Nutrition values are estimates.

K
Recipe by

KrazyBadal

All recipes by this chef →

Good to know

How long does pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie take?
About 130 minutes in total: 30 minutes to prepare and 100 minutes to cook.
How many people does it serve?
6 as written. Change the servings above the ingredients and every amount scales to match.
What can I use instead of onion?
2 shallots per onion.
What can I use instead of celery sticks?
Fennel, same weight.

Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to cook it.

Rate this recipe

Sign in to rate and review this recipe.

Arroz con pitu de caleyaSoupy rice with chicken

A pitu de caleya is a cockerel raised free in the lanes, or caleyas, of rural Asturias; its firm, flavourful meat needs long stewing, and families around Villaviciosa and Grado still cook it for feast days. The stew is often finished as a soupy rice, so the deep chicken juices go into every grain. Use the best free-range chicken you can find. The braise includes dry white wine; replace it with extra stock and a squeeze of lemon if you want it alcohol-free. Chef's tip: brown the chicken slowly and deeply; that colour is where the flavour of the whole pot comes from.

by KrazyBadal 1 views

Moist banana bread

The blacker the bananas, the better the loaf. This one is mixed in a single bowl with melted butter and a little brown sugar, so it's soft, deeply banana-y and keeps well for days.

by KrazyBadal 0 views

Chicken tikka masala

Marinating the chicken in spiced yoghurt keeps it tender, and a few minutes under a hot grill gives it the smoky char of a tandoor. The sauce is rich but not heavy, finished with a little cream and dried fenugreek leaves.

by KrazyBadal 0 views